Struggling to Survive: Over 800,000 Workers Rely on Government Aid Amidst Minimum Wage Situation
- ~ 2 min read
State disburses seven billion euros to 826,000 individuals through citizen supplement program - State shells out seven billion euros to 826,000 individuals accused of overcharging consumers
Germany's unsettling revelation has emerged as government data shows that approximately 826,000 workers received additional "Universal Basic Income" (UBI) last year due to their income not being sufficient to make ends meet. This staggering figure indicates a financial burden of around seven billion euros on the state. These numbers come from the German government's response to a request made by Cem Ince, a member of the Left Party, and were made available to the news agency DPA [1]. The number of these so-called "UBI top-uppers" has risen for the first time since 2015 [2], raising concerns and sparking debates about minimum wage increases.
In 2015, Germany introduced the statutory minimum wage, initially set at 8.50 euros per hour. The number of "UBI top-uppers" gradually decreased, as shown by statistics, from around 1.2 million in 2015 to roughly 796,000 people in 2023. However, an increase has been observed in 2024, breaking this trend [2]. The current minimum wage sits at 12.82 euros, and discussions are underway within the Minimum Wage Commission regarding potential increases [3]. Federal Chancellor Friedrich Merz has expressed optimism about achieving and desiring an increase to 15 euros by 2026, a proposal that employers have deemed as excessively high [3].
Ince, a member of the Left Party, uses these figures as an argument for a substantial raise. "It's nonsensical that over half a million workers are still dependent on state aid," Ince stated in an interview with DPA [1]. "We should invest in childcare facilities and kindergarten spots instead of subsidizing low wages and perpetuating labor exploitation."
Data from the Ministry of Social Affairs indicates that state spending on additional UBI increased from 6.19 billion euros in 2023 to 6.99 billion euros in 2024 [1]. In 2024, communities reliant on UBI besides a wage - such as families or couples - received a combined total of 11.61 billion euros in state aid [1].
Many "UBI top-uppers" are employed in mini-jobs, as stated in a Bertelsmann Foundation study [4]. Almost half of the workers receiving supplementary UBI are employed in mini-jobs, with around two-thirds having salaries far below the average.
This situation has brought the issue of minimum wage increases to the forefront, as workers struggle to live on their wages despite being employed. The outcome of the Minimum Wage Commission's decision, expected soon, will have a significant impact on low-wage workers and the state's expenditure on UBI top-ups.
Sources:1. DPA: More than 800,000 employed workers receive state aid in Germany2. Wirtschaftswoche: Minimum wage – More than 826,000 employees receive top-ups3. SPON: Zeit organization: Topping up basic income for 826,000 employed people costs the state seven billion euros in 20244. Bertelsmann Stiftung: Most UBI top-uppers work mini-jobs
Enrichment Data:
Germany's proposed minimum wage increase centres on reaching approximately EUR 15 per hour by 2026.
Proposed Increases in Minimum Wage
- The German Trade Union Confederation (DGB) advocates for a minimum wage of EUR 15.27 per hour by 2026, aligning with EU guidelines recommending minimum wage to be approximately 60% of a country's median income.
- The Social Democratic Party (SPD) supports a minimum wage of EUR 15 per hour, a stance emphasized in recent election campaigns.
- The coalition government parties (CDU, CSU, SPD) have agreed that the commission should consider collective bargaining trends and the 60% median income benchmark, potentially leading to a minimum wage near EUR 15 by 2026.
- SPD Secretary Tim Klüssendorf suggests that a figure slightly below EUR 15 (e.g., EUR 14.92) might be acceptable but could be questionable for legislation.
Arguments and Context
- The SPD presents the EUR 15 minimum wage as vital for enhancing purchasing power among low-income workers and a cornerstone of social democracy.
- Opposition parties stress the importance of the decision being made independently by social partners in the Minimum Wage Commission instead of being politically determined.
- The rise to around EUR 15 is seen as a way to ensure fair wages consistent with economic growth and social standards in Germany and the EU.
- At present, the minimum wage is set to increase to EUR 12.82 per hour beginning January 1, 2025, yet this figure remains below the EUR 15 target.
- The ongoing debate on minimum wage increases has sparked discussions within community institutions, politics, and business circles, as the proposed increase to approximately 15 euros per hour by 2026 has significant implications for general-news and economics, particularly for vocational training programs that provide skills necessary for the workforce.
- In light of the increasing costs of financing the Universal Basic Income top-ups for over 800,000 workers, there is growing concern about the impact of a potential minimum wage hike on the overall economy and the state's financial situation, prompting deliberations on alternative solutions for enhancing employment opportunities and vocational training, thereby reducing reliance on state aid.
