Political Leader Reul on A2 Highway: 'Truck Serves as a Deadly Weapon'

Political Leader Reul on A2 Highway: 'Truck Serves as a Deadly Weapon'

Germany's Heavy Vehicle Safety Crackdown: Fines too Low, Says Minister

In a bid to ensure safety on Germany's roads, particularly in heavy traffic, authorities in North Rhine-Westphalia (NRW) recently conducted a large-scale operation. The operation, which involved over 750 deployment forces, aimed to prevent accidents and increase safety, with the Dortmund city treasury, police, and other authorities participating.

The operation, which took place on August 8, 2025, at a commuter parking lot on the A2 near Dortmund, revealed concerning findings. Many trucks were found to have cargo that was not properly or at all secured, a violation that can lead to accidents and pose significant safety risks. Drivers who fail to secure their load with the prescribed means are subject to a fine of 53.50 euros.

However, NRW Interior Minister Herbert Reul has criticized these fines, considering them too low. He stated that heavy vehicles, if not properly managed, can be fatal. Reul's perspective arises from concerns that the penalties do not sufficiently discourage dangerous behavior or compensate for public safety risks, especially given legal limits on raising fine amounts and practical challenges in enforcement.

The issue of heavy vehicle safety violations and their associated fines has been a subject of debate in Germany. Fines for violations ranging from ignoring weight limits to improper loading are often viewed as inadequate to prevent repeated or serious offenses relative to the risks and damages such violations can cause.

For instance, regulations enforced by authorities like the Federal Office for Goods Transport (BAG) and police impose fines between approximately €200 and €3,000 for technical and regulatory breaches concerning trucks, including roadworthiness and load limits. However, these fines are sometimes viewed as inadequate to deter violations that pose significant safety risks.

The controversy over fines is evident in incidents like the one on the A1 motorway bridge near Cologne, where fines for breaking weight bans were initially set high but later required reduction after legal challenges, leading to financial losses for the city budget. This incident highlights disputes over whether fines fairly reflect the severity and risk of violations.

Comparative context shows fines for other serious traffic offenses (e.g., extreme speeding) can be in the range of €900 or more, paired with license suspension, suggesting that heavy vehicle fines might lag behind in punitive impact despite the potentially greater risk heavy vehicle violations carry.

The NRW Interior Ministry published these figures to highlight the urgency of the issue. Nationwide, there were approximately 4,000 truck accidents with injuries or fatalities in 2024. In the same year, the police in NRW found more than 35,000 violations of driving and rest periods, with around 48,000 checks conducted.

The police officers were transported to the control points by bus, and the operation controlled over 30 locations, including motorways and inner-city streets. Many drivers were found to be on the road without the appropriate driver's license, another safety concern that underscores the need for stricter enforcement and potentially higher fines.

The operation in Dortmund was part of a statewide measure, and it serves as a reminder of the ongoing efforts to ensure safety on Germany's roads. The issue of heavy vehicle safety violations and their associated fines remains a topic of discussion, with calls for reform to better reflect the risks and dangers posed by these violations.

(Editor's note: The project operates on a voluntary basis.)

[1] Fines for Heavy Vehicle Safety Violations in Germany: Too Low? [2] The Controversy over Heavy Vehicle Fines on the A1 Motorway Bridge near Cologne [3] Regulations and Fines for Heavy Vehicle Safety in Germany [4] Truck Accidents in Germany: A Call for Action [5] Comparative Analysis of Traffic Fines in Germany

1. The NRW Interior Minister, Herbert Reul, has expressed concerns that fines for heavy vehicle safety violations in Germany may be too low, as they do not sufficiently discourage dangerous behavior or compensate for public safety risks.
2. The controversy over heavy vehicle fines is evident in incidents such as the one on the A1 motorway bridge near Cologne, where fines for breaking weight bans were initially set high but later required reduction after legal challenges, pointing towards ongoing disputes over whether fines adequately reflect the severity and risk of violations.
3. Taking the comparative context into account, fines for other serious traffic offenses, such as extreme speeding, can be higher, increasing the question of whether heavy vehicle fines in Germany accurately reflect the potentially greater risk these violations carry.

Read also: