Assessing Green Hydrogen in the Global South: A Post-Hype Examination

Assessing Green Hydrogen in the Global South: A Post-Hype Examination

Green hydrogen, touted as a potential climate-friendly energy carrier and economic driver, is making progress, but its global implementation is proceeding more slowly and selectively than initially expected. This news article explores the current status of green hydrogen, its geopolitical implications, potential benefits, and risks, particularly for developing countries.

Programs like H2Global, H2Uppp, and the H2-Diplo network in Germany aim to stimulate investments, promote technology exports, and enable fair supply chains. However, the global rollout of green hydrogen is facing challenges, with many announced projects in the Global South, such as Namibia, South Africa, Chile, facing delays or suspensions due to high capital costs, lack of firm demand or offtake agreements, infrastructure challenges, and competition from direct electrification options.

In Europe and other regions, ambitious demand targets are being revised downward because some hydrogen applications prove uneconomical or less viable than expected. Despite these setbacks, green hydrogen production capacity is expanding from about 20 GW currently toward hundreds of gigawatts planned globally. Regulatory clarity, investment security, and international collaboration are needed to accelerate deployment.

Countries endowed with renewable resources and sovereign wealth funds, such as Saudi Arabia, UAE, and Oman, are positioning themselves as early leaders, using green hydrogen to gain geopolitical influence and diversify their economies away from fossil fuels. Developing countries with less stable governance and financing challenges are receiving comparatively little investment, mitigating some concerns of green colonialism but also limiting their participation in the new energy economy.

Green hydrogen offers significant benefits for developing countries. It can generate new green jobs, drive industrial innovation and exports, and provide a decarbonization pathway especially for hard-to-electrify sectors. It may also offer energy access and economic diversification if coupled with supportive policies and international cooperation. However, high upfront capital costs, infrastructure requirements, and the risk of stranded investments pose financial risks. Developing countries could also be marginalized if investment favors politically stable or resource-rich countries, potentially exacerbating inequalities. Overreliance on hydrogen export revenues might lead to economic vulnerabilities if global demand fluctuates or competitors emerge.

In sum, while green hydrogen holds promise as a climate-friendly energy carrier and economic driver, actual global uptake is currently more cautious and uneven than initially envisioned. For developing countries, realizing benefits depends heavily on securing investment, stable governance, and targeted policies to overcome financial and infrastructural barriers.

Notable developments include Gustavo Petro's proposal for a cooperation between Colombia's Ecopetrol and Brazil's Petrobras, as a shift from oil to hydrogen. Foreseeable demand for green hydrogen is well below the targets set by the EU and its member states. Investments in green hydrogen are lacking in poorer countries with unstable governance. President Biden made "clean" hydrogen a pillar of the Inflation Reduction Act in the US. Colombian President Gustavo Petro declared green hydrogen as a potential "oil of the future" in 2024. Chancellor Scholz announced investments of over four billion euros in the hydrogen market in 2022. Germany is promoting the ramp-up of green hydrogen with over 20 bilateral hydrogen partnerships. China is investing heavily in electrolysis to dominate the hydrogen market.

In conclusion, green hydrogen, while promising, requires careful consideration, particularly for developing countries. A balanced approach that addresses financial, infrastructural, and geopolitical challenges is necessary to ensure a fair and sustainable global transition to green hydrogen.

1. The economic and social policy implications of green hydrogen are significant, particularly for developing countries, as it offers opportunities for job creation, industrial innovation, and decarbonization.
2. Science and environmental-science play crucial roles in the development and implementation of green hydrogen, as researchers seek to improve its efficiency and reduce its costs.
3. Climate-change and energy policies, along with finance and political support, are essential for the widespread adoption of green hydrogen, as they can provide regulatory clarity, investment security, and international collaboration.
4. The global news surrounding green hydrogen is filled with discussions on its potential benefits and the challenges facing its implementation, such as high capital costs, infrastructure requirements, and competition from direct electrification options.
5. In the realm of politics and policy-and-legislation, countries like the US, Colombia, Germany, and China are taking steps to invest in and promote green hydrogen, although developing countries with unstable governance may receive comparatively less investment, potentially limiting their participation in the new energy economy.

Read also: